The WWE Friday Night SmackDown Ratings Crisis


Orton Vs. Christian Money in the Bank MatchI rarely blog about WWE television ratings but the recent trend on Friday Night SmackDown will make this blog an exception. SmackDown ratings are dropping at a record pace and are now on their ninth straight week with less than three million viewers.

I see all of the blogs and reports on a weekly basis about SmackDown’s ratings decline but really haven’t paid much attention. A bad rating here and there isn’t going to make a big difference on most weeks. However, I think there is a big story there when any program is over two months in a ratings slide and SmackDown is the story.

[adinserter block=”2″]Last week’s SmackDown rating has finally put this program in crisis mode. SmackDown scored a 1.63 cable rating, down from a 1.69. SmackDown averaged 2.33 million viewers, down from 2.40 the previous week. Smackdown is on a nine-week streak of less than 3.0 million viewers.

SmackDown saw its first drop come after Randy Orton defeated Christian for the WWE world heavyweight title. I remember at the time reading reports that indicated the ratings slide was a fan reaction to the title change. I never bought into it. It wasn’t as if Christian was a big meter mover before the title win so why would people that be outraged that they would tune out in masses?

Maybe they would. The week before Dave Meltzer reported a very high number for the show the week before Orton’s title win.

Smackdown on 4/29 did a 1.96 rating and 3.06 million viewers, so the show is remaining at high levels.

The next week it dipped to a 1.74 cable rating, with 2.8 million viewers.

Yet we are now just a few weeks away from hitting the three month mark and unfortunately, you have to point to Randy Orton. A big part of the dropping numbers are summer ratings patterns and people generally watch less television on Friday nights in the summer. However, this pattern started back in April long before the summer season. Is Randy Orton really that much of a turnoff to the SmackDown viewers?

In the past, I could see that being that case. Yet I would argue that the Randy Orton on SmackDown is the best Randy Orton I have seen during his WWE career. He finally has that charisma that I always thought was lacking, his promos are better, his opponents are better, his feud is tremendous, his matches are better, yet he has lost more viewers as the face of the brand than anyone else in recent memory. Is it bad timing or is it The Viper?

Check out the full Camel Clutch Blog Pro Wrestling and MMA store for videos, t-shirts, books, and more.

I was never a regular SmackDown watcher until the start of the Orton vs. Christian rivalry. In my opinion, I think it is the best feud that the WWE has had since the Shawn Michaels vs. Chris Jericho series. Every match is great to fantastic, the angles are fun, the promos are intense, and I don’t want to miss a moment. Ice that over a cake with regular matches from Daniel Bryan, Sin Cara, Sheamus, and Cody Rhodes and I think you have the best WWE broadcast on television, yet less people are watching.

I took a look at past SmackDown ratings and I was really surprised at how far the show has fallen. A few years ago SmackDown was doing high twos on a regular basis. The average SmackDown rating last year according to one report was a 1.8.

In my opinion the loss of Batista, The Undertaker, Chris Jericho, Edge and Rey Mysterio are really the key components missing to the SmackDown ratings mystery. Edge was a solid heel and Rey had a huge Latino following. The Undertaker was also popping in and out more a couple of years ago. Batista and Jericho had star power whether he was opening or closing the show. Instead of four superstars on SmackDown, fans have one and aren’t interested in giving the other talent a chance.

How can the WWE fix this before we are subjected to Eric Bischoff gloating about Impact beating SmackDown? The first thing they need to do is move Rey Mysterio back to the brand. He is being jobbed out weekly on RAW anyway, so it isn’t a big loss to Monday nights. Rey brought in a huge Latino audience to SmackDown and maybe they have abandoned ship. The second thing they need to do is somehow, someway bring The Undertaker back. Even if he can’t wrestle, just his presence alone on SmackDown would get people talking and spike the brand.

[adinserter block=”1″]The other question is whether it is even worth fixing at this rate? Would the WWE be better off just dissolving both brands and merging everyone together? Before I would go down that road I would merge the two WWE champions and make one touring champion between both brands. It would give the WWE an excuse to book John Cena on SmackDown and other RAW superstars on Friday nights and increase the program’s awareness. I like that the company has two champions but they need Cena on SmackDown or at least popping in and out regularly.

It will be really interesting to see what happens over the next few weeks. If the ratings continue to slide with the WWE do something drastic or will they just chalk it up to summer viewer patterns and hold tight until September? Regardless, this is certainly a ratings story worth keeping your eyes on.

WWE Randy Orton: The Evolution Of A Predator DVD

WWE Randy Orton The Viper RKO Tee Shirt

WWE Money in the Bank 2011 DVD

WWE: The Greatest Cage Matches of All Time

Brock Lesnar’s autobiography – Death Clutch: My Story of Determination, Domination, and Survival

Grab discounted WWE DVDs, merchandise, t -shirts, figures, and more from the WWE Shop on

Great Deals at!


  1. I agree that they are doing versions of the same match every week! I love the guys that are getting the time, but you gotta shake it up a bit. Also Mark Henry can not be the biggest heel on the show, and they pretty much ruined all the build of sheamus had back when they were doing the NXT angle and he was afraid of them.

    Also did you consider the fact that smackdown was moved to scifi. I was so puzzled by this because i instantly thought the ratings would go down because of this, granted i understand if they can not get another network to pick it up. But what does USA have going on friday nights that is so great? I think this could be the biggest cause, not everyone even gets scifi with the basic cable packages.

    Lastly i agree with the few that have said they need a new gm to spic things up, edge def would be a top candidate…especially with the lack of true heel power on smackdown. But more than anything with the WWE as always, they need new writers. In the words of CM Punk…..maybe the company will be better when Vince is dead.

  2. I think some of the Smackdown problem of recent weeks has to be the repetitive booking and feuding that doesn't seem to lead anywhere. I love watching Daniel Bryan, Cody Rhodes, Ted Dibease, and Sin Cara in the ring but beyond a bit of mixing things up last week these guys have been having the same storyline/feud for far too long. I

    For like a month and a half the show was Bryan/Cara swapped with Rhodes/Dibease in singles or tag, Barrett and Zeke, Christian and Orton, Natalya and the NXT girls with Alicia Fox and Tamara, etc. Just too many repeats.

    Oh, and the Raw supershows repeated these matches even further, to where you would often see these same matches twice in a week. Again, I love watching Bryan and Rhodes fight, but they need to mix the roster up more.

  3. They got to get Rey back on Smackdown. The FIRST move to Raw didn't work out. What makes them think this one will? If Taker can't wrestle, what can he do? Harass Michael Cole? Hmmmmmmmmm. LOL They should bring Edge back. He can be the new GM to replace Long. He can hit people with chairs. That wouldn't be too too physical> LOL

  4. Cole –

    1 – Taker can come back however he wants:)
    2 – It would be interesting to see if he got the title if ratings turned around. I just can't see it being a big issue. It isn't as if Christian was pushed hard and then buried. He is getting the biggest push of his WWE career. I just don't think him wearing the belt would make a difference, but your're right. Why not try?
    3 – I like Sheamus but hey, they need a change.
    4 – Agreed!

  5. 1. How could Taker come back? As an ABA replacement for Teddy Long?
    2. Give Christian the title back. I kinda want to see what happens to the ratings. His fans who have been boycotting the show will come back at least, and more Orton marks will tune in to see him chase the title. I know I've always preferred the chase to the defense.
    3. Big Zeke VS Sheamus. Replace Sheamus in the main event with Cody Rhodes or Wade Barret, at least for a little while. See what happens rating-wise.
    4. The same solution for Raw: fire all the writers and hire good ones.

Leave a Reply to Eric Gargiulo Cancel reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.