And In This Corner: HBK vs. Undertaker…No Chance in Hell


Shawn Michaels and the UndertakerHello there loyal readers. You are my loyal readers, right? In this series I attempt to provide an alternative view point to a specific topic. My subject this time is none other than the WWE “The Phenom” himself, The Undertaker.

With WWE WrestleMania 26 fast approaching I began thinking about the Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels rematch. A lot of speculation is going on as to whether HBK can end the Taker’s 17-0 streak, or will this be the last hurrah for the Showstopper. To me, there is no doubt how this one will end. This match is being booked as a test of wills. And when it comes to imposing his will, in my opinion, the Undertaker stands alone.

For nearly twenty years now, the Undertaker has been one of the driving forces in the WWE. From his days as the Dead Man, to “the conscience of the WWF”, to leader of the Ministry of Darkness, to the American Bad Ass, to Big Evil, to WrestleMania legend, one thing has remained the same. The Undertaker looks out for the Undertaker. Other than the fact that he portrays a dark persona, I don’t see the attraction that people have for him. I am not an Undertaker fan, can you tell, and here are my top reasons why.

#5 – He Never Ever Breaks Character
[adinserter block=”1″]I understand and I can certainly appreciate the art of selling your persona to the fans. I still remember being at a NWA match at the Philadelphia Civic Center in the late ‘80s and having someone show me a picture they took back stage of Ric Flair, Sting, and Lex Luger posing with their arms around each other and smiling. The problem was that they were all feuding at the time and I remember how disillusioning it felt to see them break character like that. So I get it. But Undertaker takes it to a whole new level. I have never seen him any other way, except for when he was “Mean” Mark Callous in WCW before becoming the Undertaker. To me, the moment that took it too far was the night of May 24th, 1999. That was the night of the Owen Hart tribute, Raw Is Owen. The show started with all of the wrestlers standing on the entrance ramp for the ten bell salute. All except for the Undertaker, who was leading the Ministry at the time and didn’t want to break character. Even Steve Austin, who was nearly paralyzed by Owen, came out at the end to toast Owen and left us with the moving and lasting image of that lone beer can left in the ring for Owen.

#4 – He Never Loses A Feud
Name me one feud he has had that he has lost. The closest he has come is with Mankind back in 1996, almost fifteen years ago. Even when he loses individual matches, they are quickly followed up by Taker getting his revenge and rendering the previous victory all but irrelevant. I know the fashionable thing is to bash Triple H for all the people he has supposedly “buried”, but please tell me just who has the Undertaker ever elevated. Who has ever gotten the last shot in with him? Because it is so rare for Taker to do the job for an opponent, when it does happen it seems somehow grander and more epic. Part of the reason that the series of matches he had with Batista in 2007 were so good was that an opponent was finally allowed to hold his own against him.

#3 – In Ring Work
Let me clarify this one right away. When he wants to, the Undertaker has some of the most impressive moves and agility for a man his size that has ever been seen. WHEN HE WANTS TO. He basically took off the first part of the last decade and was sleepwalking through matches. He was out of shape, injury prone, and lazy in the ring. How many careers did he almost end by not being able to cleanly execute his “Last Ride” finisher? For the last few years he has improved his work rate to a much more consistent level, but still takes nights off in my opinion. Say what you will about the limited move sets of a John Cena, or the backstage politics of a Triple H. One thing you cannot slight them on is the consistent effort they put out in the ring.

#2 – He No-Sells Like No Other
[adinserter block=”2″]Does this really need explanation? People love to trash Hulk Hogan for ruining guys by no-selling their finishers, which of course he does. But why should the Undertaker get a pass. I can see a need for it back in the early ‘90s when he was supposed to be this unstoppable zombie like monster. But now? Why should I believe that a finisher that can take out any other wrestler is worthless against a balding wrestler in his mid forties? And as usual, Undertaker takes it too far. You want to sit up from one finisher, fine. But he can get up from multiple finishers. How does this guy ever lose?

#1 – The Streak
17-0. It sounds so absurd to me to even write that. Could any other wrestler get away with being undefeated on the biggest stage of the year for that long? Triple H catches hell just for being in the main event every year, which by the way he is not this year. John Cena is vilified for, well, just being John Cena. And yet Taker is built up for his extended run of excellence. If you have read any of Justin Henry’s amazing WrestleMania recaps you’ll see that most of the matches Undertaker has had at WrestleMania have been mediocre to downright awful. Yet year after year he goes over whoever is put in front of him.

Well there you have it. Another myth debunked, another fraud exposed. I hope HBK wins to end the Undertaker’s streak , I really do. But I just don’t see it happening. Because when it comes to protecting the aura of the Undertaker, Mark Calaway will never rest… in peace.

Vince DeHoratus lives in suburban Philadelphia with his wife and two kids. He has been a life long wrestling fan and he has passed that love onto his son. Though not quite yet “middle aged and crazy”, he is fast approaching it.

Order WWE Tombstone – History of the Undertaker

Undertaker’s Most Dangerous Matches

WWE – Undertaker 15-0

WWE – Undertaker – This Is My Yard

From the ring to your wall – WWE REAL.BIG Wall Graphics on sale now at Fat Head!


  1. I'll concede that I don't know everything about the backstage politics. I'll just say it's going to be a great match just like last years and we'll see Shawn retire at the top like he would want. Also I read this blog constantly, and between you and my Smark friends I'm getting quite a good education in how Wrestling works.

  2. First off, I would like to thank you for taking the time to leave a comment. My intent with these articles is to spark debate and I’m happy to have done that. It's nice to know that people are actually reading these. That being said, I think your premise is flawed and a little naïve, no offense. For the average wrestler, the writers control their character and how they are perceived. I’m sure Evan Bourne doesn’t want to go out and job week after week, but that’s the hand he’s dealt. The Undertaker is a different story though. He (along with Triple H, HBK, and Cena) is one of the few wrestlers with enough clout and tenure to determine their own fate. Maybe not full creative control, but pretty darn close. I don’t dislike him just for being over with the fans, I have no problem with Cena for example. I dislike him for how he has molded his character over the years, especially during the early 2000’s when he was lazy and out of shape. And just because the writers give you the power to be “the man” all the time it doesn’t mean that you have to always take it. If that were the case, Stephanie would have had Triple H celebrating his 8th consecutive year as champ by now.

  3. Hating the Undertaker because of what he gets in the company is absurd. It's not his decision is a round table decision made by the writers with the known fact that he is so impossibly over with the kids the demographic they want (read switch to PG). You might as well just hate on Cena for being popular and selling himself very well, wrestling is surprisingly a popularity contest…like everything else.

    Also the Batista series of matches wasn't just a build for Batista it completely solidified him at the top so now whatever angle he's in it's gold. I just think you're wrong in blaming the Blue Knight at Medieval Times for winner all the time, not entirely his decision but if you were that over wouldn't you want to be in that position?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.