Wednesday, May 18, 2022
HomeSportsNFL | NCAA FootballFed Up With The Jeff Fisher Hype

Fed Up With The Jeff Fisher Hype

Jeff Fisher was fired and for good reasonThe hype and propaganda surrounding Jeff Fisher by his fan boys around the country is bordering on sickening. I haven’t seen this much promotion for an overrated since Mike Shanahan and just ask Washington Redskins fans how that is working out.

I have never been a Jeff Fisher fan. I watched a head coach over the last several seasons come up short every year with excuse after excuse made for him by the national media. I watched a guy given more opportunity to win than any other NFL head coach in history yet I am in the midst of watching a charade produced by the NFL Network and many at ESPN that hasn’t been seen since, well you already know his name.

The Miami Dolphins and St. Louis Rams have each made big plays for Jeff Fisher. In a season where you have analysts and NFL reporters bloviating weekly about the merits of not paying a guy like DeSean Jackson, they are giddy with the prospect of Jeff Fisher cashing in a king’s ransom at the hopes of “selling seats,” in spite of his winning record and rumors of insubordination in his last gig. Shame on them for not giving NFL fans the real story.

[ad 6]An objective look at Jeff Fisher shows a guy that had sixteen years with the same team and never won a Super Bowl. During a time where we are seeing coaches fired in 1-3 years for not producing, Fisher had sixteen and did nothing! Well, if winning one AFC championship is something than Jeff Fisher is your man. And oh yeah about that 1999 AFC championship win…he got lucky!

Let’s go back to 1999 and take a look at Jeff Fisher’s one and only Super Bowl run…twelve years ago! There was a play, a historic Wild Card play called the “Music City Miracle” which won the Titans the game. Yes I know it isn’t how you win the game it is only about winning the game. But if not for an incredibly fluky play that will probably work once a century, Jeff Fisher wouldn’t have even made it to the Super Bowl!

So in sixteen years the man has one, yes one season in which he went to the Super Bowl and lost. NFL fans are constantly reminded thanks to NFL Films and sound bites about the ultimate prize, the Super Bowl. Winning the Super Bowl is all that matters in the NFL and anything else means nothing. In other words, Jeff Fisher accomplished nothing in 16 years.

As disgusted as I was with the Mike Shanahan hype a few years back, at least the man won multiple Super Bowl championships. Fisher not only didn’t win the Super Bowl, he has a record 5-6 of under .500 in the postseason altogether. Jeff Fisher hasn’t even made it out of the AFC divisional round in 10 years. To put it more into perspective, Fisher was bounced in his first appearances in his last two playoff games, the last one at home. Call me crazy but this guy doesn’t sound like any kind of coaching guru.

This was my recap of his last season with the Titans when I blogged about his firing last year. “We have all watched the Tennessee Titans this season and what about the way their season ended gave anyone a though that they’d be a team to reckon with in 2011? Their defense did improve, but it was hardly at a level to stop Peyton Manning on a consistent basis. Rusty Smith is a nice project but did he show you anything to make you believe he can win games next season in place of Vince Young? The running game which was the calling card of the Titans in 2009 regressed. It should also be noted that the Titans had the worst record in their conference going 2-4 against the AFC South. Can someone please explain how this makes Jeff Fisher a great coach and what owner shouldn’t fire Fisher after a season like this one?

At least I am consistent.

Fisher’s off the field issues in his last couple of seasons as head coach are also curiously forgotten. He handled his quarterback Vince Young with the maturity of a pee wee football player. He had a locker room split and in chaos his last season in Tennessee thanks to his handling of the quarterback and showing up at a charity event wearing his rival QB’s NFL jersey. Let’s not forget the chaos Fisher caused for his organization with the irresponsible contract extensions he dished out to coordinators. Aren’t these the kinds of mistakes rookie head coaches make? Yes, but this guy was in his sixteenth season!

Did he have some winning regular seasons? Sure he did. But so do a lot of NFL head coaches in a league full of parity and regular injuries. The luck always runs out in the postseason when you can’t duck the elite of the division and that is where Fisher crumbled. He was 27-21 in his last three regular seasons. Is that what Miami Dolphins and St. Louis Rams fans are hoping for? Three seasons with six wins over .500?

There is a big problem here and I thought the NFL media would learn this with Mike Shanahan but they haven’t. Instead of reporting objectively on Jeff Fisher and his coaching merits, they are more concerned about chasing the “sexy” name and creating a story for ratings, interest, and of course the hopes of their good will paying off in getting the exclusive Jeff Fisher interview. Quite frankly it disgusts me as a fan and is one of the reasons I rarely torture myself by watching those carnival NFL pregame shows or newscasts on television.

The other dirty secret here is that the over-hyped head coach hasn’t won a Super Bowl with his new team in years. Not since Jon Gruden (and some will tell you it was Tony Dungy’s team) nine years ago has a former head coach won the Super Bowl with his new team. Yet these former failed head coaches are pushed on the networks and in newspapers over more deserving candidates for reasons I can’t comprehend other than the ones I listed above.

[adinserter block=”1″]Quite frankly an NFL team would be better off picking up a hot NFL coordinator. They are more humble, less financially secure (although they will still make plenty), and bring new wrinkles to the game which give them an edge. The last three Super Bowl winning coaches are first-time head coaches who were promoted from coordinator.

So let’s hope two years from now when Andy Reid becomes a free agent and Mike Shanahan is either gone or coming off another losing season and Jeff Fisher is making more excuses for his Dolphins or Rams that the NFL media take a lesson here and think twice before singing the high praise of an over-hyped failed former NFL head coach looking for a new job.

Something tells me that’s not going to happen.

100 Yards of Glory: The Greatest Moments in NFL History

NFL Jerseys on

Madden 12 video game

NFL America’s Game Super Bowl I-XL on DVD



  1. I totally agree with all of this. As football fans, we romanticize the past and certainly "big names." The most extraordinary thing about Fisher's career was that he managed to last as long as he did with the Oilers/Titans.

    But teams will take a guy like that over an up-and-coming coordinator because they're afraid of the unknown. Even though any objective person can see that Fisher is overhyped, the Rams/Dolphins fans are salivating at this potential hire.

    And it's also the "one man's trash is another man's treasure" argument. Fans convince themselves that Fisher is gonna work out THIS time even if he didn't with the Titans. Look at Mike Murlarkey getting hired in Jacksonville. They see fit to hand over the reins of the team to this guy, meanwhile the Falcons were considering firing him and the fans were basically forming a lynch mob to burn his house down. One man's trash is another man's treasure.

    It's fun to watch though isn't it? Now I just need my Bucs to hire the right guy. Who that is, I have no earthly idea.

    • Thanks for the feedback. It is fun but I think it is a little obnoxious when guys like Fisher and Shanahan play games, more so Fisher. As for the Bucs, I think they got into the game a little too late. Hopefully they can strike gold with a coordinator rather than a rehash. Marty isn't the worst choice. At least you know you'll be in the hunt. You'll just never get there lol.

      • Yeah that's the knock on Marty. And a lot of fans down here are convinced that it'll work out THIS time, just like with Fisher. There really isn't a coach out there that people will be over the moon for, except Bill Cowher.

        Now there's another example of a guy who didn't do a whole hell of a lot relative to how long he had to do it. But, once again, he's the big name out there. Add to that the mystique that comes from him being away from the game for a few years and you've got yourself another product of the hype machine.

  2. I never thought Fisher was that good of a coach. Fisher also undermined Vince Young as a QB when Fisher would (reportedly) feed harsh criticism to ESPN's Merril Hoge. If Hoge sounded very hard on Young, it was because his buddy , Fisher was feeding him the info. It was because the Titans' owner, Bud Adams picked Young over Fisher's objections. I am not saying that Young would have become this great QB, but he did have potential , and I thought, if the story was true, he didn't need to be undermined by his Head Coach.

    As far as the Music City Miracle, it doesn't happen if the stupid Buffalo Bills coach, Wade Philips started Doug Flutie instead of that incompetent Rob Johnson. Trust me, the Bills would have won that game if Flutie were the QB. No doubt.

    Fisher has only what, 6 winning seasons? Why all the love for the guy?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Most Popular