A Split Decision That Could Have Changed UFC History

Episode 7 of the first season of the Ultimate Fighter featured a match that ended in controversy. The elimination match ended in a close split decision. This split decision may have been the most important in MMA history. These judges had the power to change the course of UFC history forever.

Going into the season, Bobby Southworth was the perennial favorite to win the entire competition. Southworth was the most seasoned of any fighter in the house. UFC knew this, Dana White knew this, and the coaches knew this when Chuck Liddell used his first team pick on Southworth.

Stephan Bonnar was barely on anyone’s radar at the time. I would argue it was more the mystique of training under Carlson Gracie that initially made him intriguing. As the show went on, Stephan’s personality would turn him into a fan favorite. As a top notch fighter, he was far from a favorite going into the season.

Southworth had been a controversial figure from episode 1. Southworth came off as a very immature athlete. Southworth continually ran his mouth, yet had to be practically kidnapped in order to cut weight for his first fight. If MMA fans hate Brock Lesnar, they would have despised Southworth. Southworth would practically get in the face of other fight losers and bark, “flawless victory” at the top of his lungs.

Southworth is probably most known for the incident with fellow fighter Chris Leben. I will get into Leben in a future blog. The gist of it is that Southworth called Leben a “fatherless bastard.” Southworth and fellow fighter Josh Koscheck came close to getting kicked off the show after pouring water on a sleeping Leben later that night.

The idea of the first season was that the fighters would have to compete in physical challenges. Most of the time, the winning team would get to pick their fight. Team Couture won the challenge. Randy Couture initially suggested that Mike Swick or Alex Schoenauer fight “the weakest link on the team” Sam Hoger. Stephan Bonnar spoke up and said he wanted to fight Bobby.

Stephan had his eyes set on Bobby from the start. Stephan loved the test, yet questioned his own decision. Stephan worried that two rounds would not be enough. Stephan later remarked that he wasn’t confident that he could stop Bobby, but knew he could stop Sam. Stephan knew from the start that if he was going to win the fight, it was going the distance.

Bonnar was a huge underdog. Forrest Griffin called him the third weakest on Randy’s team. A great moment saw Griffin (Southworth’s teammate) say to Bonnar, “Let me shake your hand before you’re officially tapped out.” Bonnar took it in good stride, yet he was truly expected to lose this fight.

The fight itself only made you want to hate Southworth more. Southworth looked cocky, but did not engage. Bonnar grew more confident as the first round progressed and started pushing the pace more and more. Southworth was not nearly as aggressive, yet seemed to counter Bonnar with almost every move. All of the fighters remarked that the round was close, but most felt Bobby won due to a key reversal.

One of the greatest moments in Randy Couture history may have came in between rounds. Couture cornered Bonnar for the fight. How brilliant of a fighting technician is Randy Couture? Randy tells Bonnar that Bobby is looking for a left hook and right hand since that is Chuck’s combination. The camera than shows Liddell telling Southworth, “Look for a left hook and a right hand.”

The second round like the first started slowly. Once again Bonnar continued to push the tempo as Southworth sat back and played defense. Bonnar seemed to have a slight edge on Southworth on the ground. Southworth connected hard on Bonnar with about 1:10 left, but couldn’t finish. The next minute may have been the minute that changed UFC history forever.

Southworth started to push but Bonnar fought back. Bonnar caught Southworth with a text book spinning back kick with exactly 0:59 to go. Southworth was stunned and Bonnar knew it. Bonnar followed up with a barrage of aggressive punches. After a back and forth on the ground, the round ended with Bonnar once again aggressively throwing punches.

Nobody from the coaches to the fighters to Dana White himself expected this one to end. The rules were that a sudden death round would be added in the event of a draw. This was by no means a clear cut case for anyone. As a matter of a fact, Randy and Chuck prepared the fighters for another round.

Dana White was surprised as he read the decision. Stephan Bonnar was awarded the win by split decision. In looking back at the fight, I will argue that the spinning back kick is what gave Bonnar the edge. Bonnar was the definitive aggressor, yet Southworth had some great counters. All being even, the kick, the time of the kick, and the damage is what won Stephan Bonnar the match.

The Ultimate Fighter Finale between Bonnar and Forrest Griffin was recently ranked as the number one match in UFC history. The argument was not just the fight, but the impact that the fight had on the sport. That fight was one kick and a split decision away from never happening. The course of UFC history may be much different today if fans tuned into see a Forrest Griffin vs. Bobby Southworth Ultimate Finale on April 9, 2005.

I can’t imagine that match being anything close to Bonnar-Griffin levels. History would have turned out to be much different for UFC and MMA. Spike may have never renewed UFC. This would have meant no more live specials on Spike. We may never have gotten Ultimate Fighters 3-9. 1.72 million people wouldn’t have watched UFC 100. Forrest Griffin may not have turned out to be one of the biggest stars in MMA. Not only would he not have been on the UFC Undisputed cover, there may have never been a game at all.

This split decision was that monumental to the history of the company. One spinning back kick in a match held in a gym may have been the most significant strike in UFC history.

Watch this episode online and judge for yourself at .

Order the UFC Presents The Ultimate Fighter – Season 1 on DVD by clicking here.

Place your UFC bets on BetUs.com by clicking here or Boddog.com by clicking here.

New Items Marked Down! Shop the UFC Sale at the UFC Store.

Grab last minute UFC 101 tickets at StubHub.com or get 5% off the ticket purchase at PurchaseTix.com ! – Enter the Coupon Code: fiveforyou.

Order Forrest Griffin’s book Got Fight?: The 50 Zen Principles of Hand-to-Face Combat by clicking here.

(Visited 317 times, 1 visits today)

Eric G.

Eric is the owner and editor-in-chief of the Camel Clutch Blog. Eric has worked in the pro wrestling industry since 1995 as a ring announcer in ECW and a commentator/host on television, PPV, and home video. Eric also hosted Pro Wrestling Radio on terrestrial radio from 1998-2009. Check out some of Eric's work on his IMDB bio and Wikipedia. Eric has an MBA from Temple University's Fox School of Business.

More Posts - Website

Follow Me:
TwitterFacebookGoogle PlusYouTube



Welcome to the Camel Clutch Blog. The CCB was born in 2007 and features blogs from over 50 different writers. Articles from the Camel Clutch Blog have been featured by some of the world's most respected websites including; CNNSI.com, Foxsports.com, Yahoo News, Business Insider, MSNBC, NBCsports.com, and more.

Writers Wanted

Do you have a passion for blogging? The Camel Clutch Blog is proud to have featured over 50 guest bloggers and contributors since its inception. The CCB is a great outlet for your blogging or a great way to promote your own site, blog, and/or podcast through Guest Blogging. The CCB reaches millions of people per year and you can be sure you will be read when you post on the CCB. Email Eric Gargiulo at [email protected] if you are interested.

Add to Flipboard

Connect with me

Link to my Facebook Page
Link to my Rss Page
Link to my Twitter Page
Link to my Youtube Page
To Top